Came home and was playing some Metriod Prime 3 and saw my Cleaner Shrimp nipping at my clam. Never thought that would happen... Anyone heard of this? The clam is brand new and I was able to save it and move it to the other end of the tank. My Cleaner Shrimp is territorial and won't come to the other end of the tank.
a few questions. how is the clam doing now that you moved him? I seen and heard of shrimp nipping at clams when they were dying, but not a healthily clam. was he nipping at the mantle or the shell?
__________________ read and learn and ask questions. knowledge is power
I had the same thing happen with my cleaner shrimp and a clam and a few days later it became obvious that the clam was dying...........and the shrimp obviously knew it.
The clam looks to be doing good now. It was doing a bit of both as far as nipping, the mantle and the shell. The shrimp nipped off the spout of the clam, now their is just a hole there. Thanks for all your responses, I am going to monitor the clam and let you know how it is doing and let everyone know.
are you sure it nipped off the excurrent siphon? the incurrent siphon just looks like a flat hole...kinda like a slit.
i've had no trouble with even a large CBS and my clams...in fact, the CBS could walk on the clams and clean the shell margins without so much as a flinch from my clams.
as mentioned, when a clam is in mortal distress, cleaner shrimp, Nassarius snails, and a host of other critters will indeed make short work of it. if a shrimp was picking at a healthy clam it would be at the margin of its mantle as NO healthy specimen would stay open long enuf for the shrimp to attack its center.
Let me just say that a Skunk Cleaner Shrimp is,without a doubt,the most reef safe Invert I have ever come across.
To do harm to Marine life is frankly out of the question.
I suspect a cleaning was mistaken for something else.
Let me just say that a Skunk Cleaner Shrimp is,without a doubt,the most reef safe Invert I have ever come across.
To do harm to Marine life is frankly out of the question.
I suspect a cleaning was mistaken for something else.
actually, while not being malicious, skunks have been known to pester SH by constantly trying to clean them, thus, stressing them out. we actually recommend adding them to a SH setup "with caution".
Well it happened and it died and to answer past posts the clam was a crocea and it was about 3 to 3-1/2 inches. I believe that the clam was not healthy and the shrimp took care of its dying off process. Thanks for everyones help here. My wife and I have decided to stop getting clams as this is our second loss, but on a high note I have a forest of Xenia that will never quit!
Sorry to hear about your loss.........I know exactly how you feel. It took me a while to buy another Clam after 2 losses.
On the brighter side, I was able to get a number of Clams that were and are healthy and surviving. Everybody knows that adequate lighting is required for Clams but a lot of people don't know that Phytoplankton is a must to keep healthy Clams thriving.
What kind of clams did you get and what kind of lighting do you have?
I have Croceas: 5 total
4 healthy, thriving clams in the 210ga under the 400W Solaris LED Array unit (which is too expensive to recommend although I like this unit very much)
and 1 in the 24ga Nano under a 150W 20K MH which is doing very well.
My daughter has a 65ga with CF lighting that I am not going to subject the clams to unless I can figure out a way to vent the heat for a MH supplemental light.
Like I mentioned before, a lot of reefers do not realize the importance of phytoplankton in the reef. It is literally the base of the food chain for a reef and a lot of filter feeders (clams, feathers, coral, naupali, etc) feed on phytoplankton exclusively.
The down side is that (live) phytoplankton is expensive unless you culture and grow it yourself which is easy and comparably inexpensive. Check out Melevsreef.com -
Found new clam being eaten by shrimp!! 
. Never thought that would happen... Anyone heard of this? The clam is brand new and I was able to save it and move it to the other end of the tank. My Cleaner Shrimp is territorial and won't come to the other end of the tank.
icon under their name to add to their reputation. 
