I searched this site but did not see this addressed. I am considering upgrading from my JBJ 24NC to either the Solana 34 or the CAD 39. My LFS has the Solana in stock and it is a nice set-up. However, they have never heard of the Cad 39 and their conclusion was the Solana had to be better, otherwise they'd have heard of the Cad. Well, I don't buy that logic. Some other saltwater/reef forums have this discussion going with no conclusion as to whether one is superior to the other. Anyone here have an opinion?

LOL! I love that logic (or lack thereof.) IMO this is one of those discussions like Coke & Pepsi An awful lot is personal preference. I have heard good things about both. I was also impressed with the Finnex M all in ones at MACNA but I am not sure if they have anything >30 gallons. I have heard that the ATO on the Solanas is too small to be really useful.

Thanks CarmieJo. I understand the Solana is coming out with an improved model this Spring with a much larger ATO.

I hadn't heard that but I have not been paying attention either. :) I do like the fact that the a-i-o tanks are getting more complete with fuges, skimmers, ATO's, etc.