View Full Version : ID this tang please! Pescaiolo 10-17-2007, 12:50 PM If you could please ID this fish, I would greatly appreciate it. I found it at a LFS and they have it labeled as a "blue tail tang". It has a blue edge on the dorsal and anal fins, I think this is where they got the name. I am seriously considering getting it but the price tag is deterring me a little(199.99). Its about 6 inches long and very active. Well without further ado here is the fishy! :mrgreen: Amphibious 10-17-2007, 03:47 PM Clarence,
In my humble opinion, you are asking for trouble, here's why I think that.
You have a 55 gal system housing, Zebrasoma flavescens, Paracanthurus hepatus, Acanthurus leucosternon and a few other critters. It's the 3 Tangs that are going to cause problems. If you are getting by with these 3 Tangs without problems you are fortunate. Adding a fourth 6" Tang of unknown species (at this time) there is going to be territorial terror. We know that Tangs are notoriously susceptible to Ich often caused by stress. Adding the new Tang is likely to cause stress. Ich is almost always present in your aquarium and the new comer could bring it in, too.
Adding just one more may be the straw that breaks the camel's back and you pay a heavy price in losses. I wouldn't do it. But, you need to make that decision. At $200 it's a bit pricy for what it looks like in the picture.
Just my opinion.
Dick Pescaiolo 10-17-2007, 04:34 PM I just purchased a 120g(48x24x24) and it will be delivered next Wednesday. I have decided if I get this one, I will turn my Zebrasoma in to make room for it, if they don't sell this one by the time I get moved in the next 3 to 4 weeks hehe. I will be starting a log on here as soon as I get everything set up. 120 DT, 55g sump and 29g refugium. I can't wait!!! :D Thank you for the input Dick, as always its appreciated very much! :) CarmieJo 10-17-2007, 09:16 PM Clarence,
Congratulations on your new tank! lReef lKeeper 10-17-2007, 09:57 PM Clarence, a 120 is still a 4' tank (is your new one not ??). it is recommended to have at LEAST a 6' tank to keep even 1 tang. i have to agree with Dick on this one. BOTH tanks, IMO, are still to small to keep tangs in. they are documented as covering hundreds of miles every day in the wild, while just grazing on algae. in a 4' tank, i would go with no more than 2 tangs at MAXIMUM.
i have a 6' 125gal DT with my purple, hippo, and chevron, and in my 8' frag tank i have my sohol by himself. i think that when i get time to redesign my rocks, i am going to throw the chevron in the 100gal sump to even things out some.
i hope this helps and gives the fish a healthy, happy place to live. Pescaiolo 10-18-2007, 03:32 PM I see...well I have decided against getting this tang. I would still like to ID it but since everyone is telling me not to overcrowd my tank with tangs I'll stick to the ones I have. They get along fine and I don't want to mess the balance up.
Thanks Carmie! I am so happy! This is my first drilled tank hehe. I can't wait to get moved and set it up!
Bobby thanks for the input. I eventually want to go to a 72Lx24Hx30D, or something similar, as my DT but I have to wait until I get settled and buy a house out here. The 120g is a half step so to speak. I also want to use it as a prop tank once I get what I really want hehe. I have seen several tangs being kept in a 48" tank. Reef Videos (http://www.reefvideos.com), Carl's 150g, he has several tangs in a 48" tank. I'm not saying its right but it seems possible.
Once again a big thank you to everyone for replying! :D lReef lKeeper 10-18-2007, 03:45 PM I have seen several tangs being kept in a 48" tank. Reef Videos (http://www.reefvideos.com), Carl's 150g, he has several tangs in a 48" tank. I'm not saying its right but it seems possible.
this greatly depends on the tang species. it is doable, but not recommended. even for the smaller tangs. Pescaiolo 10-18-2007, 04:07 PM I am not one to shun advice from experienced hobbyists so I will not get anymore tangs. As a matter of fact I think I'm not going to be getting anymore fish, corals are a different story though. :p Thanks for the advice Bobby! :D lReef lKeeper 10-18-2007, 06:29 PM you got it buddy. i would not say dont get anymore tangs ... just get a HUGE tank first !! lol |